looked for a site on keeper stats and found one
the only way to judge by stats over a long period is the save % of shots on target to saves
I've found an up to date site that has this seasons and last seasons stats
20/21
1 _________ Nathan Baxter _________ Acc'ton Stanley _________ 78.3
2 _________ Christy Pym _________ P'borough Utd _________ 75.8
3 _________ Jayson Leutwiler _________ Fleetwood Town _________ 75.6
4 _________ Tomáš Holý _________ Ipswich Town _________ 74.8
5 _________ Craig MacGillivray _________ Portsmouth _________ 73.7
6 _________ Matt Ingram _________ Hull City _________ 72.9
7 _________ Chris Maxwell _________ Blackpool _________ 72.8
8 _________ Alex Palmer _________ Lincoln City _________ 72.7
9 _________ Lee Burge _________ Sunderland _________ 72.4
10 _________ Jack Stevens _________ Oxford United _________ 71.6
11 _________ Ben Amos _________ Charlton Ath _________ 71.2
12 _________ William Jääskeläinen _________ Crewe Alexandra _________ 70.9
13 _________ Matija Šarkić _________ Shrewsbury _________ 70.2
14 _________ Ben Garratt _________ Burton Albion _________ 69.2
15 _________ Alex Cairns _________ Fleetwood Town _________ 69.1
16 _________ Jay Lynch _________ Rochdale _________ 69.1
17 _________ Jack Bonham _________ Gillingham _________ 69.0
18 _________ Michael Cooper _________ Plymouth Argyle _________ 67.9
19 _________ Jonathan Mitchell _________ Northampton _________ 67.8
20 _________ Andy Fisher _________ MK Dons _________ 66.2
21 _________ Jamie Jones _________ Wigan Athletic _________ 65.8
22 _________ Anssi Jaakkola _________ Bristol Rovers _________ 64.9
23 _________ Toby Savin _________ Acc'ton Stanley _________ 63.2
24 _________ Connal Trueman _________ AFC Wimbledon _________ 61.7
25 _________ Gavin Bazunu _________ Rochdale _________ 61.2
26 _________ Matej Kovar _________ Swindon Town _________ 58.8
27 _________ Harry Burgoyne _________ Shrewsbury _________ 58.5
28 _________ Kieran O'Hara _________ Burton Albion _________ 56.8
29 _________ Joe Day _________ Bristol Rovers _________ 56.5
21/22
1 _________ Ben Amos _________ Wigan Athletic _________ 78.6
2 _________ David Stockdale _________ Wycombe _________ 78.0
3 _________ Gavin Bazunu _________ Portsmouth _________ 76.7
4 _________ Bailey Peacock-Farrell _________ Sheffield Weds _________ 74.2
5 _________ Jack Stevens _________ Oxford United _________ 73.5
6 _________ Jamie Cumming _________ Gillingham _________ 73.4
7 _________ Michael Cooper _________ Plymouth Argyle _________ 73.0
8 _________ Joshua Griffiths _________ Lincoln City _________ 70.2
9 _________ Ron-Thorben Hoffmann _________ Sunderland _________ 70.0
10 _________ Pontus Dahlberg _________ Doncaster _________ 69.2
11 _________ Viktor Johansson _________ Rotherham Utd _________ 69.2
12 _________ Kyle Letheren _________ Morecambe _________ 67.9
13 _________ William Jääskeläinen _________ Crewe Alexandra _________ 67.6
14 _________ Ben Garratt _________ Burton Albion _________ 67.4
15 _________ Jökull Andrésson _________ Morecambe _________ 66.7
16 _________ Marko Maroši _________ Shrewsbury _________ 66.0
17 _________ Joel Dixon _________ Bolton _________ 64.7
18 _________ Alex Cairns _________ Fleetwood Town _________ 64.3
19 _________ Scott Flinders _________ Cheltenham _________ 64.3
20 _________ Dimitar Mitov _________ Cambridge Utd _________ 63.6
21 _________ Craig MacGillivray _________ Charlton Ath _________ 63.3
22 _________ Nik Tzanev _________ AFC Wimbledon _________ 61.4
23 _________ Andy Fisher _________ MK Dons _________ 61.3
24 _________ James Trafford _________ Acc'ton Stanley _________ 56.8
25 _________ Václav Hladký _________ Ipswich Town _________ 55.2
as for the defence
EBL has been fooling many for too long
Pennington is a waste of time, just take a looks at his stats this year
and Pierre just cant be bothered